to desire the replica

posted on: November 21st, 2008

In some instances, I am naive. I know this to be true and perhaps this is one of those times. It seems as though it would be so fucking easy for China to embrace–or at least accept– the Dalai Lama’s “middle way” approach and grant autonomy to Tibet. In all of these years of exile, the movement has been asking for that which they already had prior to the Chinese invasion in 1949. They weren’t asking for independence and there is a huge difference between the two.

China has continued it’s hard line stance and refuses to consider autonomy which is now pushing many Tibetans, including the exiled government, to reevaluate it’s methods. The middle way has thus far produced no results and frustrated Tibetans are now talking about a movement to independence which will surely result in a military crack down, death, and even tighter restriction for those in the region.  The recent meeting in India of the exiled Tibetan government has prompted China’s Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang to state that;

“Any attempt to separate Tibet from Chinese territory will be doomed.”

Some Tibetans fear that an independent movement would effectively end the sporadic talks that have been taking place with Beijing since 2002, but in reality, those talks have proved ineffective and therefore of little value to the end goal. It’s as though China wants the Tibetans to rise up so that they can squash them and be able to “justify” the move to the rest of the world.

I just don’t fucking get it. I’ve tried, but I just can’t understand the bully reasoning and unbending stance of China. If you can enlighten me, please do.

Share and Enjoy:
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • StumbleUpon

Stever Says:

The problem with Tibet is that there is no real benefit to anyone else in the world to truly stand up to the Chinese on this.

Tibet is too remote and of no economic significance or political significance. So China will get away with it.

On the other hand they make territorial claims over Taiwan. But they won’t take the step of “enforcing” their historical claim ono Taiwan because the economic significance of Taiwan is far too great for the world to ignor it. Enforcing their claims in Taiwan would spark a real war, enforcing it in Tibet only produces minor grumblings from politically insignificant protesters and foreign celebrities.

They also can’t back down and agree to any “middle way” else they loose credibility on anything else they lay claim too. This may be critical to China at this time in history as they have only just started to come out of their shell and participate on the world stage. Now that they are becoming an economic superpower they can’t un-flex that muscle else they may not be allowed to flex other muscles when they need too.

Tibet may just be SOL.

Leave a Reply